Friday, June 14, 2024

Which Is Proper for You?


You’ve in all probability heard of the comparability between freestanding vs. non-freestanding tents.

The variations between the 2 will be complicated. However don’t fear! That’s why we’re right here that can assist you perceive extra about every tent design.

Right here’s the fast model:

Freestanding tents use a community of inside poles to keep up their form.

Non-freestanding tents use a single vertical pole and depend on stakes to assist them preserve their construction.

Whereas this may occasionally appear easy, there are a number of variations between the 2 tent sorts.

This text will cowl a couple of of these variations and when to make use of every kind of tent.

Freestanding Tents

Freestanding tents comprise an inside, double-wall construction supported by tent poles.

These tents get their identify from staying erect from their inside construction. They don’t depend on exterior help, like stakes.

One of these tent makes up the vast majority of the “conventional” tents you’ll see in an outside retailer or on the path.

Execs Of Freestanding Tents

  • Simple to arrange
  • Moveable
  • Double-wall design
  • Roomy inside
  • Properly-insulated

One of these tent is nice for newcomers as a result of it’s comparatively straightforward to arrange and, as soon as it’s arrange, is prone to keep that approach.

And, when you’ve constructed a freestanding tent, you possibly can even transfer it across the camp to a different spot if wanted.

Freestanding tents additionally are inclined to have extra inside area, giving campers room to maneuver and retailer their gear.

Additionally, most freestanding tents are double-walled. That is tremendous efficient at maintaining warmth contained in the tent whereas additionally maintaining condensation out.

The dependable construction, roomy inside area, and double-wall design make freestanding tents the kind of tent you wish to wait out a storm in.

Whereas these tents can be utilized all through the seasons, they actually shine in additional excessive climate situations.

Cons Of Freestanding Tents

  • Heavier
  • Riskier in excessive winds
  • Reliant on poles and stakes to face upright

The primary downside for the freestanding tent mannequin is the burden. They require a tent construction, a rain fly, poles, and stakes. So, they are often heavier than non-freestanding tents.

Typically, a normal 2-person, freestanding tent can weigh in wherever from 3–4 lbs.

Whereas this won’t sound like a lot, this quantity of weight can add up in your pack throughout a protracted trek.

When utilizing a freestanding tent on a backpacking journey, attempt to break up up the tent supplies among the many group. Be sure that one particular person isn’t caught with your complete weight of the tent.

It’s additionally value mentioning that there’s a wind danger with freestanding tents in the event you don’t stake them down.

As a result of they preserve their construction on their very own, freestanding tents can catch wind and be blown away.

Whereas it may be tempting to not, at all times stake down your tent to maintain it in a single place.

Lastly, the poles used for freestanding tents are normally tent-specific. Campers can discover themselves in a pinch if a pole breaks on the path.

If the pole can’t be patched up with duct tape, the camper might want to attain out to the precise producer for a alternative.

Non-Freestanding Tents

Non-freestanding tents are an ultralight tent different that doesn’t have pole-system construction.

They’re as a substitute erected by a single help pole and a collection of stakes.

The most typical help pole utilized by campers is a mountaineering pole since many already carry a pair with them on lengthy treks.

Nevertheless, in a pinch, campers can use a stick or different related objects, making these extraordinarily adaptable tents.

Execs Of Non-Freestanding Tents

  • Ultralight
  • Fast to set-up
  • Waterproof & Water resistant

The most important benefit to non-freestanding tents is their weight (or lack thereof).

As a result of they solely contain a single-walled tent, a single pole, and a collection of stakes, they’re much lighter than freestanding tents.

Typically, a 2-person non-freestanding tent will common round 1 pound in weight.

Moreover, when you get acquainted with the method, organising a non-freestanding tent is fast and straightforward.

All you’ll must do is choose piece of floor, insert the help pole, and stake down the perimeters of the tent.

One other essential distinction for non-freestanding tents is that they’re single-walled and don’t use a rain fly. To account for this, all the material used is handled to be waterproof.

When you’re caught within the rain whilst you’re organising camp, non-freestanding tents will preserve the tent inside dry through the downpour.

Cons Of Non-Freestanding Tents

  • Single-wall design
  • Unreliable in bad-weather
  • Simply collapsible
  • Poor insulation & air flow

Typically, non-freestanding tents will not be as dependable in unfavorable climate situations.

As a result of the set-up course of for non-freestanding tents depends on a single mountaineering pole and a set of stakes, the margin of error is small.

Which means if the help pole or any stake is affected by the climate, you danger your complete tent construction collapsing.

Additionally, the single-wall design is just not as efficient at trapping warmth contained in the tent. You may really feel colder in a non-freestanding tent than you’d in a freestanding one.

Plus, they aren’t as efficient at air flow or stopping condensation from constructing. Sadly, that built-up moisture can drip onto you and your gear whilst you’re sleeping.

Freestanding Vs. Non-Freestanding: In contrast

Efficiency Issue Freestanding Tents Non-Freestanding Tents
Set-Up & Breakdown   x
Stability & Wind Resistance x  
Flexibility In Campsite Choice x  
Weight & Packability   x
Sturdiness & Longevity x x

Set-Up & Breakdown

Set-Up & Breakdown

On the finish of the day which sort of tent is simpler to arrange will rely by yourself ability set and the way acquainted you’re with every kind of tent.

When you’ve been on the path with any explicit tent, you grow to be a professional in organising and breaking camp.

From an effectivity perspective, non-freestanding tents are going to win out throughout set-up and breakdown.

These tents solely require you to insert a mountaineering pole into the middle of the tent, after which stake down the surface edges of the tent.

It’s also possible to arrange non-freestanding tents within the rain with out getting the within of the tent moist.

Compared, freestanding tents want many poles inserted into the construction of the tent to set it up.

After the tent has been arrange, you’ll want to stake the construction down in a number of spots.

As a result of freestanding tents are double-walled, you need to arrange the construction earlier than you possibly can put the rain fly up. This might probably get something contained in the tent moist throughout inclement climate.

It’s additionally simpler to wash freestanding tents as a result of their construction is extra intact. You possibly can choose up the tent and shake any particles out by the unzipped door.

Compared, a non-freestanding tent goes to be a bit tougher to wash.

Winner: Non-Freestanding

Stability & Wind Resistance

Stability & Wind Resistance

When robust winds or dangerous climate is within the forecast, it’s at all times higher to have a freestanding tent.

These tents will not be solely roomier, however they’re additionally higher at weather-protection.

In unfavorable climate situations, non-freestanding tents rely on the one level of construction. They’re one robust gust away from collapsing.

A stake popping out of the bottom can compromise the delicate construction, which may occur in robust winds.

Winner: Freestanding

Weight & Packability

Weight & Packability

That is an space the place non-freestanding tents are a transparent winner.

They don’t have additional material layers or want additional poles or stakes. Non-freestanding tents are usually lighter and extra compact than freestanding tents.

On common, the burden of a 2-person non-freestanding tent is normally round 1–2 kilos.

Freestanding tents common wherever between 3–4 kilos for a 2-person design.

So, they’ll be heavier since they want additional poles and stakes, which may add weight and bulk to your pack.

Winner: Non-Freestanding

Flexibility In Campsite Choice

Flexibility In Campsite Selection

When you’re in search of reliable flexibility and flexibility, freestanding tents might be your finest guess.

Freestanding tents will be arrange virtually wherever as a result of they don’t depend on stakes as closely as non-freestanding tents.

Non-freestanding tents depend on staking to keep up their general construction.

You possibly can stake freestanding tents down utilizing different strategies with out compromising the construction.

This generally is a troublesome process to do for non-freestanding tents, particularly on rocky or uneven floor.

In both case, tenting on rocky or uneven floor would require different staking strategies. The “large rock, little rock” method is normally finest for this.

This system entails tying the tip of the guyline round a smaller rock. Then after pulling the guyline taut, you place a bigger rock on the “tent” aspect of the smaller rock to lock it in place.

Winner: Freestanding

Sturdiness & Longevity

Durability & Longevity

Each choices are robust contenders in the case of sturdiness.

For probably the most half, freestanding and non-freestanding tents are related in supplies.

What issues is how light-weight these supplies are. Producers will sacrifice materials sturdiness to make these supplies “ultralight”.

The extra light-weight the fabric, the extra seemingly it will likely be weak to tearing on the path.

This trade-off will be value it for the correct camper, however it’s at all times value contemplating.

Winner: Tie

Components To Contemplate When Selecting Freestanding VS Non-Freestanding

Tenting Setting & Circumstances

Freestanding tents are the extra versatile possibility.

Their double-wall construction actually shines in dangerous climate and will help preserve you hotter and dryer throughout chilly and moist situations.

Non-freestanding tents are on no account ineffective throughout these situations. They’ll seemingly preserve you protected against the weather, simply not as successfully as a freestanding tent.

Nevertheless, each varieties of tents will work properly in reasonable situations. When you’re headed out on a trek in reasonable situations and are particularly frightened about pack weight, a non freestanding tent will serve you properly.

Journey Period

When you’re headed out for a protracted trek and pack weight is a major concern, a non-freestanding tent could be an important tent possibility.

As a result of this sort of tent can compress down in measurement and doesn’t require poles, it’s seemingly that you simply’ll save area and weight in your pack.

Non-freestanding tents will be an particularly nice possibility in the event you’re mountaineering alone. If you need to carry everything of your shelter by yourself again, you need it to be lighter.

Nevertheless, in the event you’re headed out in additional excessive climate situations or with different individuals, a freestanding tent is the best choice for you.

This tent design’s double layer will preserve you additional insulated.

Bonus factors in the event you can break up up the additional weight of the freestanding tent amongst a number of packs!

Expertise Degree

To place it merely, extra trip-ending errors will be made with non-freestanding tents than freestanding tents.

That being mentioned, in the event you’re a newbie within the outdoor world, I like to recommend you begin with a freestanding tent.

One of these tent is extra simple to arrange and can preserve you heat and protected against the weather.

They’re additionally good for quite a lot of environments and climate situations, that means they’re barely extra versatile.

When you’re available in the market in your first tent buy, freestanding is a good design to begin with.

Non-freestanding tents are extra superior and are finest for people who’re extra skilled within the outdoor world.

Finances Concerns

There is no such thing as a giant price distinction between the 2 based mostly on their freestanding vs. non-freestanding designs alone.

But, you’ll seemingly discover a distinction if the tent is classed as light-weight or not.

A light-weight freestanding tent might be related in worth to a light-weight non-freestanding tent. However they’ll seemingly have totally different precise weights.

Following this identical logic, an “common” freestanding tent will price roughly the identical as an “common” non-freestanding tent.

Mainly, the extra high-tech supplies a tent has and extra light-weight a tent is, the upper the worth tag.

FAQs

What Are The Foremost Advantages Of A Freestanding Tent?

Freestanding tents are an extremely dependable and versatile kind of tent, particularly in dangerous climate. When you’re caught in a storm that lasts a couple of days, you need a freestanding tent.

Usually talking, freestanding tents have extra inside area when in comparison with non-freestanding tents.

Moreover, their double-wall design retains out condensation, so it gained’t drip on you in the course of the night time!

How Do I Anchor A Non-Freestanding Tent In Rocky Terrain?

If you end up setting in rocky situations, organising your non-freestanding tent will be tough. You may want to make use of different strategies.

When you can’t discover any good floor for staking, you possibly can at all times tie the tip of your man strains round rocks, utilizing the “large rock, little rock” methodology.

Is One Kind Of Tent Extra Suited For Solo Tenting Than The Different?

Purely based mostly on weight, non-freestanding tents are an important possibility for a solo camper who has to hold their pack alone.

Nevertheless, solo tenting with a freestanding tent is totally doable – so long as you’re fantastic with just a little additional weight.

How Do Tent Supplies Issue Into The Freestanding Vs. Non-Freestanding Debate?

Most tents use a mix of waterproof handled polyester and nylon supplies.

Non-freestanding tents’ single-wall design makes use of much less supplies and material general.

This single wall of material has to insulate the within of the tent whereas additionally defending them from the surface. So, it’s normally handled to be waterproof.

Compared, freestanding tents use extra material and supplies general to make up each layers of their double-wall design.

Whereas all layers of material are usually waterproof, this sort of design depends closely on a water-proof rain fly layer to maintain everybody dry.

Can I Convert A Freestanding Tent Into A Non-Freestanding One?

No. As a result of the 2 varieties of tents have totally different designs, you can’t convert a freestanding tent right into a non-freestanding tent.

Is There An In-Between Choice For The Two Sorts Of Tents?

Sure! When you’re trying to dabble in non-freestanding tent types, however aren’t utterly able to take the leap, you possibly can strive a semi-freestanding tent possibility!

Semi-freestanding tents have an inside pole that runs from the highest to backside edges. This maintains a big a part of the tent construction, and stakes do the remaining.

As a result of the pole is inside, these tents are extra steady than non-freestanding tents. Although they’re additionally lighter than your common freestanding tent.

Remaining Ideas On Freestanding Vs. Non-Freestanding Tents

When you’ll want to resolve between a freestanding vs. non-freestanding tent, it’s wholly as much as you.

Your stage of expertise, the tenting situations of your journey, and your private preferences all issue into this choice.

Freestanding tents are going to be one of the best for newcomers. They’re additionally nice for campers headed into excessive climate situations.

However in the event you aren’t keen to hold just a little additional weight, they might not be for you.

Non-freestanding tents are finest for extra skilled outdoor individuals.

They’re finest for extra reasonable situations or people who’re particularly frightened about their pack weight.

With all of those elements in thoughts, you possibly can select the tent that’s finest for you!

Extra Tent Comparisons:

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles